Own Trucks or Aggregate Them? Why Kobo360 Left Last-Mile Delivery
Short answer: Use contracted vehicles first when demand is uneven, routes vary and capital is scarce. Own vehicles only when one repeatable lane can keep each asset earning for at least 70% of its available operating time and the added control creates more contribution than finance, maintenance and idle capacity cost. Price the return journey explicitly. A profitable outbound load can become a loss once the empty trip home is included.
Kobo360 began around last-mile delivery, then moved into an asset-light long-haul model connecting cargo owners with independent truck operators. Founder accounts point to weak last-mile volume and the difficulty of owning trucks, while long-haul aggregation offered larger loads and the possibility of matching return journeys.
The fashionable answer is “asset light”. That is incomplete. Contractors reduce fixed capital but increase supplier control, quality and payment risk. The right choice follows lane economics, not startup identity.
Use the Asset Burden Test
The Asset Burden Test compares four burdens across owned and contracted capacity.
| Burden | Owned fleet | Contracted network | |---|---|---| | Capital | Purchase or lease, deposits and depreciation | Onboarding, guarantees and working capital | | Utilisation | You absorb idle time | Carrier absorbs some idle time, price reflects it | | Control | Direct standards and scheduling | Standards enforced through selection and data | | Variability | Fixed capacity can become a constraint | Supply can flex, but may disappear at peaks |
Add a fifth line for your market's real bottleneck. It might be driver quality, insurance, border delay, maintenance or payment timing. A spreadsheet that omits the constraint produces a theoretical fleet.
What Kobo360's pivot exposed
Kobo360 was founded in Nigeria and initially worked in last-mile e-commerce delivery. It moved towards long-haul freight, matching cargo owners with trucks rather than building a large owned fleet. A 2018 TechCrunch account describes the asset-free model and the company's reported early trip volume.
The commercial problem differed from urban parcel delivery. Long-haul shippers needed reliable capacity across fragmented trucking supply. Truck owners needed loads, payment and fewer empty return journeys. Aggregation could improve matching without Kobo360 financing every vehicle.
A later TechCrunch review of Kobo360 also illustrates the operational complexity behind the marketplace label. Carriers may need payment before the shipper settles, which transfers working-capital pressure to the platform even when it owns no truck.
My position is that an asset-light logistics company should not buy vehicles to fix weak supplier discipline. Ownership can hide a poor lane by giving the founder something to dispatch. Buy capacity only after the lane itself is proven.
Calculate the whole journey
For each lane, calculate revenue and direct cost from the vehicle's current base until it returns or takes the next paid load. Include collection distance, waiting time, loading, fuel, tolls, driver time, maintenance allocation, damage, insurance, administration and payment delay.
Return-load probability is not a footnote. If the vehicle earns £900 outbound but has a 60% chance of returning empty at £300 cost, expected empty-return cost is 60% × £300 = £180. Price the lane using that expected cost until actual matching improves.
Contracted quotes may bundle some items and exclude others. Confirm who pays detention, failed delivery, fuel changes, cargo loss and cancellation. A cheaper quote with vague liability can become the expensive option.
Compare control by outcome
Do not assume ownership guarantees service. Measure pickup punctuality, damage, proof of delivery, communication and claims resolution for every vehicle, including your own.
| Control need | Owned response | Contractor response | |---|---|---| | Specialist equipment | Fit and dedicate asset | Certify a narrow carrier pool | | Peak demand | Hire or leave orders unserved | Add approved capacity | | Driver behaviour | Recruit, train and supervise | Standards, checks and sanctions | | Tracking | Install directly | Require compatible data feed |
If a contractor network fails, identify whether the cause is selection, incentive, process or genuine supply scarcity. Buying trucks fixes only the last one reliably.
Worked example: Pennine Freight Link
Pennine Freight Link is a fictional UK operator testing a Manchester-to-Bristol lane. One owned 18-tonne truck costs £2,900 a month in finance and insurance, £850 in tax, systems and depot allocation, and £3,300 for a driver. Variable fuel and maintenance cost averages £310 per round trip. It can complete 12 trips a month, but current demand fills only eight.
Owned monthly cost is:
£2,900 + £850 + £3,300 + (8 × £310) = £9,530
At £1,250 revenue per trip, revenue is £10,000 and contribution is only £470. One four-trip demand drop creates a serious loss because fixed cost remains.
A vetted contractor charges £930 per round trip. Pennine adds £85 per trip for dispatch, checks and claims reserve. For eight trips, cost is:
8 × (£930 + £85) = £8,120
Contribution is £1,880. At 12 trips, contractor contribution is £15,000 - £12,180 = £2,820. The owned truck would cost £10,770 at 12 trips and contribute £4,230, so ownership becomes stronger once utilisation is stable.
The crossover is the decision. Pennine contracts until it has three months of at least 11 monthly trips with evidence for return loads, then re-evaluates one owned vehicle.
Build a carrier network as an operating system
Verify licences, insurance, vehicle condition, driver status, safety record, ownership and bank details before the first load. Recheck time-sensitive documents. Use a small paid route test before assigning valuable cargo.
Set service rules for acceptance, tracking, arrival windows, proof of delivery, incident reporting and payment. Pay reliably. A platform that delays carrier money while collecting later from shippers is using suppliers as involuntary lenders.
Requirements for operator licensing, driver hours, insurance, employment status and cargo vary by country and vehicle. In the UK, use current official guidance and qualified transport, legal and tax advisers. Contractor language does not by itself determine legal status.
What to do over the next 30 days
During week one, calculate full round-trip contribution for your top three lanes. Separate paid kilometres, empty kilometres and waiting hours.
In week two, qualify at least five carriers against the same safety, insurance and service standard. Run one paid test load with each suitable carrier.
During weeks three and four, compare outcomes and contribution with any owned vehicle. Do not buy on the strength of one busy week. Require three months of stable utilisation above your written crossover, secure finance under a downside case and confirm who supplies the return load. If the lane is unproven, keep the capital free.
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
What utilisation justifies buying a vehicle?
Use 70% of available operating time as a first screening threshold, then calculate your own crossover from fixed cost, variable cost and contractor price. The percentage is an indicative working guide, not an industry rule. A specialist vehicle may justify lower utilisation because the margin is higher, while an ordinary van may need more. Measure paid time, not merely engine hours. Require stability across at least three months and stress-test a 25% demand fall before financing an asset or signing a long lease.
Are contractors always more expensive per trip?
They often charge more per used trip because their price includes asset cost, idle time and profit. That can still be cheaper for you when demand is volatile because you pay only for capacity used. Compare total monthly contribution at several volumes, including management, claims and working capital. An owned vehicle may win at high utilisation. A contractor may win below the crossover. Do not compare a carrier invoice with fuel alone; include the owned vehicle's finance, driver, maintenance, insurance, depot and empty time.
How many carriers should I approve for one lane?
Approve enough to cover normal demand plus one credible backup without spreading work so thinly that nobody prioritises you. For an early lane, three to five carriers can expose service variation while remaining manageable. The right number depends on frequency, specialist equipment and peak volatility. Track acceptance and performance by carrier. A list of 100 untested registrations is not supply. A smaller pool that has completed paid test loads, maintained documents and received payment reliably is more valuable during a genuine peak.
Who should carry cargo-loss risk?
Allocate it explicitly in contracts and verify that insurance matches the actual goods, route and liability. Do not assume the carrier's general policy covers every load or that your marketplace wording removes responsibility. Confirm valuation, exclusions, excess, claims evidence and payment process before dispatch. Rules vary by jurisdiction and transport mode, so obtain qualified local advice. Commercially, keep a claims reserve even where another party is liable because recovery can take time and customer relationships require prompt handling after a loss.
How do return loads change pricing?
They spread the round-trip cost across two paying journeys. Price outbound work initially as if the return may be empty, using an observed probability rather than a promised match. When return matching becomes reliable, you can share part of the saving through a lower price while retaining contribution. Avoid quoting both legs cheaply before either is confirmed. Track origin, destination, timing, equipment and load compatibility, since a nearby return that requires two idle days may be worse than returning empty.
Does an asset-light model need less working capital?
Not necessarily. Carriers may require deposits or payment at pickup, while shippers pay 30 or 60 days later. The platform then finances the gap without owning vehicles. Calculate cash tied up per load and multiply by concurrent trips. Add disputes and failed collections. Negotiate shipper deposits, faster terms or finance only after contribution supports the cost. A profitable marketplace can fail through timing. Treat promised customer payment as a receivable, not cash available to pay the truck or fund the next load.
When should I leave last-mile delivery?
Leave when route density cannot cover dispatch, driver and vehicle cost within a defined test period, and an adjacent model offers stronger repeat demand with the same capabilities. First repair obvious pricing and route-clustering problems. If 30 days of measured delivery still shows too much empty travel or waiting, stop expanding the area. A pivot into long haul, warehousing or software needs its own demand test. Kobo360's move is evidence of one company's context, not proof that last mile is generally unattractive.
Comments (0)